"I went off and read the books after the audition and I
read the first four books in one sitting – you know – didn’t wash, didn’t eat,
drove around with them on the steering wheel like a lunatic. I suddenly
understood why my friends, who I’d thought were slightly backward, had been so
addicted to these children’s books." - Jason Isaacs on the Harry
Potter series
So why do people like Harry Potter? I have a few theories.
I know some of you are thinking this. Don't lie.
First, the world that Rowling creates is rich and expanisive
– yet not overwhelming like Lord of the Rings or Game of Thrones. Let’s be
honest here, your first time reading The Fellowship of the Ring is pretty
difficult and don’t get me started on the first Game of Thrones novel (I still
haven’t finished it). The worlds created by Tolkien and Martin are so detailed
and masterfully created that it’s often hard to follow the plot and dialogue
when the characters are making archaic references to things that happened
hundreds of years ago or referring to elaborate family trees or histories. The Harry
Potter world is fantastically immersive while still being simple enough to
follow.
I should point out that this isn’t because Rowling doesn’t
have her own person Silmarillion-esque catalogue of obscure HP related facts
and family trees – she gives the reader enough detail without making them
cringe.
"I checked this out weeks ago for a bit of light reading" aka hardcore Tolkien fans with the Silmarillion.
Second, the attention to detail and the little tidbits you
didn’t realize at first meaning a whole lot more than you thought they did. For
example, Argus Filch, the grouchy caretaker/janitor at Hogwarts always knows
when students are wreaking havoc; he’s notorious for giving out detentions…
he’s always watching. Just like Argus from Greek mythology – the 100 eyed giant
that was tasked to guard precious items by Hera. When you notice one detail
like that – so many more come forward. Remus Lupin – in Roman mythology Remus
and his brother Romulus were raised by a wolf and found Rome and Lupin
obviously comes from the Latin word for wolf “lupa.” To add to the symbolism,
Sirius Black and Peter Pettigrew. Who sold out the Potters to Voldemort?
Obviously Peter, whose animagus (or animal form they can turn into at will) –
definitely not Sirius who transforms into a dog, a paragon of friendship and
loyalty.
I could continue with that train of thought but I’ll refrain
for your sake and mine. But if you’re interested in more allusions or symbolism
in Harry Potter I wrote my senior English paper on it in high school and I
still have it…
This tortoise understands me.
That conveniently enough brings me to my third point:
nerdiness and community. The Harry Potter books and movies created a new
community of avid readers from all walks of life. The books were great for
children to grow up alongside Harry, but they were also interesting and
compelling enough for adults too. Sure at the time there were huge cult
followings for Buffy and Star Trek and Lord of the Rings, but Harry Potter
reached a larger audience by including children and by widening the niche
market for coming of age fantasy tales.
Author John Green’s vlog to his brother Hank explains as
much, if you start at the 41 second mark and watch until 1:43 or so that's the segment that is really relevant to my post.
So that’s why I think Harry Potter is so popular – it’s easy
to get into but it’s not boring, there is so much detail that to this day I’m
still realizing things I didn’t notice the first dozen times I’ve read the
book, and the community of Harry Potter lovers is a great place to not only
discuss all of the aforementioned topics, but it’s also so wonderful to be in a
theater/room, full of people all super excited for the same event.
I'd also like to add a quick disclaimer that I didn't think warranted another blog post. While I love HP, I realize I've been coming across as a blindly adoring psycho fan. I love the series, but it's only because it was such a huge part of my life for a long time and I've grown to admire so many aspects of it. I guess you could compare it to a sport you've been playing since you were little - eventually that thing that's been a part of your life for so long almost becomes an identifying feature of your inner self. I'm also a really big nerd. That much is apparent. But yeah, I do like things other than HP, and I actually read/watch a wide array of genres.
ReplyDeleteI totally agree with you. Unlike Star Trek and Lord of the Rings, Harry Potter reaches a larger audience because the movies and books off a fantasy life that the current century is very interested in. the movie has a little bit of everything, love, magic, good vs. evil, even ghosts. I enjoyed Harry Potter because you never knew who was on which side, but it was not like the show Lost where you always had 20 questions that never got answered.
ReplyDeleteTotally agree with you on the worlds each of the stories are set in. I think J.K. Rowling's world is so easy to understand because we live it with Harry Potter, just in the Muggle World.
ReplyDeleteI have to say that while I enjoy the Harry Potter world immensely, as I grew up with it since I was a kid, I do not think that it is any less complex than The Lord of The Ring trilogy, or the Hobbit. When I think of complex fantasy series I think of series like The Wheel of Time, or if you want something truly complex The Malazan Book of the Fallen but that is a series that is not for the light hearted reader.
ReplyDeleteI think the reason people of all ages enjoy Harry Potter so much is that the world in the Harry Potter books closely resembles our own world and it gives hope to people that are looking for something to escape into that still contains a bit of reality to.