I want to go back a few classes now, and discuss Merlin one more time. We
had a class discussion about why Merlin has changed over time. In Geoffrey of
Monmouth’s story of Merlin, he is a old man who goes out of way to isolate him
probably because of the weight that knowledge put on him. The power he
possesses is seeing the past and future. In the Once and Future King, Merlin still is an old man, but seems more of
laughable character in his old age. He’s wise, but also a quirky old man. Then
moving on in time, we now have the Merlin
television show where he is a young man, who is still figuring out his path and
can be odd, but he also mischievous, clever, and compassionate. He has a sense
of duty and honor towards Prince Arthur. He uses his magic to move things, and
protect those he cares about. He is part of a community.
Why has Merlin changed from old to young? Why has he become more clumsy?
Why do his powers change? My feeling on this is that Merlin’s character meets
the need of the times. In the past old men were considered wise and respected
for their age, which is why Geoffrey of Monmouth created a character who is
older and wise to the point that it was a burden for him. In today’s time
however, society finds the old more useless, and are more concerned about the
life that young people will create, which is essentially what the television
Merlin does.
While observing the evolution of Merlin, a consistent idea of him being
a little foolish sticks out, which makes me think of The Sword in the Stone’s Merlin. (He also says a good lesson in magic)
http://youtu.be/xZ9fixoPBPk
Post 2/5
I think this video has singlehandedly doubled my desire to have a ridiculous beard when I get older.
ReplyDeleteOn Topic: I wouldn't say that we view older people as "useless", but I would say that the change to Merlin for the TV show was absolutely done for narrative/demographic reasons. I'm just not entirely sure what those reasons are, other than "The young people will LOVE a young Merlin!"